Paul v Constance (1976)
Facts:
Mr Constance separated from his wife. 2
years after the separation, Mr Constance and set up a home with his lover, Mrs.
Paul and lived with her until his death. They shared their earnings and the
household expenses. Mr. Constance received a sum of money as compensation for
an industrial injury. He deposited the money into his bank account ( under his sole name), but made it clear
that both Mrs. Paul and himself are to use the money jointly. Mr Constance
assured Mrs. Paul that `This money is as much yours as mine'. When Mr. Constance died intestated , Mrs Paul
claimed that he had created an express trust in her favour while Mr. Constance’s
wife argued that the money belong to her husband’s estate which would
automatically goes to her.
Held:
(CA)
The Court of Appeal held that the word “this
money is as much yours as mine” was sufficient to constitute a declaration of
trust in favour of himself and Mrs. Paul. Although the word `trust' was never
used, it was clear that Mr. Constance had intention to create such trust.